Dalton Roberts

--from the
 Chattanooga
 Times Free Press


 
Main Page

Shopping Mini-Mall

Times Free Press Archives

 


WE ARE RESPONSIBLE TO QUESTION  
12-10-04

A part of our society’s lifestyle needing attention is the questioning of our political and business leaders. Most of the ills of the world come from trusting leaders too much.

The time for leaders has come and gone. It is time we trusted ourselves. To save mankind and a civilization worth saving, we must become our own leaders.

Still there will be basic leadership posts and those who offer themselves must realize their major need is interrogation. Those they serve have the right and responsibility to question their motives, views and personal histories. It is the only way to clarify their fitness to serve.

Any leader who even hints it is unpatriotic to question them on any issue should be removed as promptly as possible, The appeal to patriotism, as someone has said, is the last refuge of the scoundrel.

When I served in an elected office and hired department heads, I told them I expected loyalty when they could see I was right and honest questioning when they thought I might be wrong. I said, “It will bother me more for you to remain silent and watch me walk off the bluff than any other thing you can possibly do. I need to be questioned. I need to be surrounded by honest people with the guts to speak their minds.” I often laughingly said I over-trained them. Sometimes our staff meetings more resembled a debating society.

Interrogation assures that the deeper needs of society are brought out. Politicians are often satisfied to make a big thing of shallow programs they see as potentially popular. Let the people talk long enough and they will swim out of those shallow waters and begin to structure ideas that lead to dramatic shifts in the quality of life.

A good local example was the aquarium. I have a tape of a morning call-in show where I was sharply criticized over my support for “that big fish tank.” How long has it been since you heard the aquarium called that? The idea came out of community discussions where people looked at all kinds of potential projects to revitalize downtown. Some of our top business leaders then generously supported it. Would the elected leadership of the community have had the guts to support it if they had not clearly known it spun out of the minds of our own people?

Watch those old Nazi documentaries on the History Channel and you will clearly see the dangers of “yes men.” Once Hitler got the military under his thumb, he tolerated no disagreement. At no time did he offer himself to his staff or the German people for interrogation. Instead, he had the head of any person faintly questioning anything he said or did.

Hitler was not stupid. He was mentally ill and it would have come out if the people had been given an atmosphere and an arena to interrogate him. We see in his story that loyalty to a leader can actually be loyalty to his personal fantasies and paranoia.

Germany was under the boot of Hitler for less than a decade but Russia was a totalitarian state for seven decades. No nation in history has suffered more than the Russian people. Stalin had big social functions with his spies all over the room reporting back to him any tiny questioning of any aspect of his rule. Over 25 million Russians died.

To blindly follow a leader is a form of psychological impairment and social imprisonment. To the extent that any nation practices lockstep loyalty to its leaders, it will be an unsafe place to be.

The effect of blind loyalty on the economy is certain. Creativity – the arena of ideas – is the real pot of gold in any society and creativity is always stifled in a lockstep society. Creativity is thinking outside the box and when the box is loyalty, it stifles enterprise and ideas.

Nothing good prospers in a “loyal” locked-down mind.

DALTON'S WEBSITE: www.daltonroberts.com

This material should be treated as copyrighted by the Chattanooga Times Free Press and the author.  It should not be reproduced commercially without permission.